February 2022 Update


Demolition is nearly finished and renovations are underway!  We have completed the move of the church office and donated furniture to the church.  Upstairs bedroom floors have been refinished and new ceiling lights (homier and more efficient) have been installed. The windows are being restored by Window Woman (lead paint removal, sash repair and reglazing).  Lead paint has also been removed from all of the window sills.  In the upstairs bathroom, a new tub/shower and washing/dryer connection are in place.


Downstairs , in the kitchen, an interior dividing wall has been removed, plumbing rerouted and new, shorter, windows installed.  Removal of the hall carpet revealed a hardwood floor which will be refinished.  The now empty church office will be repurposed as a space for the Pastor to meet with guests, separate from the residence.  Emergency lighting and exit signs have been removed.


We are excited about turning the corner from demolition to rebuilding and restoration, and are glad we can share evidence of the progress with you! Please visit the gallery to the left to learn more.


Our Historic House at 12 Center Street

1793  Built as a parsonage 

2004  Converted to church offices 

2022  Returning to its original role 

An 1845 map of Exeter featuring the church and parsonage.

 The Beginnings 


Sometime around 1790, our congregational ancestors decided to build a home for their pastors on a plot of donated land adjacent to the church. About three years later, the spacious four-bedroom parsonage was ready for its first occupant, the Reverend William F. Rowland.

Soon after, the congregation approved another ambitious project—a new church building: the 1798 structure we continue to use.  It is the third church building constructed on the site. 

We haven’t built a new structure since 1798 but have renovated and revised the use of both buildings multiple times over the last two centuries. According to our in-house architectural expert, Lynne Monroe, the parsonage’s late 18th century bones lie beneath a mid- to late-19th century re-do in the then-popular Italianate style. The façade was updated, window openings changed, and the rear ell added. 

Our parsonage was home to 19 settled ministers, beginning with William Rowland and ending with Michael and Jane Henderson in 2003.  Interim pastor Robert Curry was the last official resident after the Hendersons left.

No one lived in the parsonage longer than Rev. Rowland – 38 years – and more than a few ministers lasted just a year.

The Twentieth Century

This picture is of the Martin family’s living room – now our Church office in the rear of house. The window has been replaced with a door.

The third-longest resident (20 years, 1936-1956) was the Rev. Paul Martin, whose son John Martin, of Exeter, is often a guest singer at Sunday services. John, who spent his first 13 years in the parsonage with his parents and younger sister, loved to attend the Exeter Brass Band concerts, but had to be home before they ended.

Young John didn’t miss much; he could hear the rest of the concert from his upstairs bedroom. He recalls grabbing his toy boats and heading downstairs when rains flooded the cellar and exploring the nooks and crannies in the attic and basement. The grounds around the parsonage were his play spaces and it was also where his mother hung the family’s laundry.  John remembers breaking his arm when he tripped on a tree stump on the lawn close to Bixler House, then a two-family home.

John said a minister’s job in those days was 24/7/365, so living next to the church was convenient. 

In the early 2000s, many pastors – including our newly called pastor, Nancy Rockwell—were opting out of parsonage living in favor of home ownership for both financial and privacy reasons. 

That’s when our parsonage had a “career change” – from home to office. In recent years, however, housing prices have increased so dramatically that pastors cannot afford to buy or rent within a reasonable commuting distance of the church.

The Transformation Has Begun…

…from an office back to a home. 

Immediately after the congregation voted in June 2021 to proceed with the project, trustees and volunteers got busy.  

  • Kitchen: volunteers have gutted the space and prepared it for new windows, insulation, cabinets, countertops, floor and appliances.
  • 2nd floor bathroom: new washer/dryer hook up will be installed
  • Throughout: volunteers removed carpet; stairs will be repaired; lighting/signage required for office space will be removed
  • Energy/safety: attic insulation will be refreshed; windows will be repaired; new sash locks and deadbolt door locks to be installed
  • Garage: will be demolished and replaced
  • Office spaces: The church office, resource room, and our refugee resettlement space will be returned to spaces in the church building.


We are so grateful for all the pledges and contributions we have already received! We are off to a strong start, and hope that our whole congregation will join in to support this worthy project. 




What Comes Next?

The Timetable

The parsonage will be ready in June 2022.

The Bottom Line

We need to raise $150,000.

The church trustees project the following expenses:

Kitchen:  $46,500

Electrical, carpet and floor repair, insulation, window repair:  $58,540

Garage:  $44,750

How You Can Help

Please join us as we work together to make this parsonage project a reality!

There are two ways to pledge:

1. By pledge form: Simply download the attached pledge form and either send it to the church email at church@exeterucc.org or mail it to 21 Front Street, Exeter, NH 03833.

Click here to find the form: https://www.exeterucc.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/Parsonage-Project-Pledge-Form-2021-1.pdf

2. Or, pledge entirely online by going to our capital campaign link on Tithely. You can even set up automatic payments, if you so choose.

Click here to pledge on Tithely: https://tithe.ly/pledge/#/campaign/4237785